Go to a better blog!


You can find a better version of my blog at http://www.adammarkus.com/blog/.

Be sure to read my Key Posts on the admissions process. Topics include essay analysis, resumes, recommendations, rankings, and more.

July 05, 2012

Q&A with a Member of the Tuck MBA Class of 2013

My former client, Tuck2013 is an MBA candidate at Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth. Prior to MBA, he worked for an investment bank. After graduation, he plans to go back to his company. His answers are particularly insightful and should prove useful to anyone considering application to Tuck.
--------------------------------


Adam: What parts of the program have you liked the most? The least?

Tuck2013: I just finished the first year and so far I like the core subjects in Tuck, though I haven’t yet taken so many electives. The first-year program in Tuck gave me intensive trainings as a general manager and broadened not only my skill set but also the career perspectives.
The core program in Tuck is highly integrated. The professors teaching core program are sharing the curriculum and they make the core subjects more connected with each other. For example, in Fall A, we learned micro-economics and then in Fall B, we used the knowledge learned in micro-economics in modeling class. Actually, this modeling class was held as a joint-session by the modeling professor and the micro-economics professor.  As this example indicates, in Tuck, the students can learn core subjects in an integrated program, which is more practical.
The core program covers all basic subjects as a manager like leadership, micro- and macro-economics, marketing, strategy, presentation and so on. Of course we can exempt the class which we are already familiar with, but basically in the first year, we don’t have the option to focus on what we want to do, which can be either good or bad. But learning broad subjects was actually very good for me, because I could find my weakness and blind spots as a manager leading the company. In addition, learning the subjects new to me was really fun. I worked in derivative sales in an investment bank before Tuck, but in Tuck I pretty much enjoyed the subjects outside my expertise like strategy and marketing, which broadened my career perspective.
The workload required in the first year was heavy. However, I think heavy workload was good, because getting through the first-year in Tuck gave me confidence and I could learn the efficient time management.    
What I didn’t like in the first year was that I couldn’t carve out enough time to enjoy winter in Hanover. Though I bought a yearly pass for Killington, the famous ski resort in North East, which is 45 min drive from Tuck, I couldn’t use the pass enough to recover the cost. So I hope that I can play with snow more next year.

Adam:  What has most surprised you about your first year?

Tuck2013: One of the things surprising to me was very supportive Tuck community including not only students and families but also faculty and program office. Almost every class has review sessions and professors and teaching assistants spend as much time as possible to support the students. If we have a problem, we can talk to MBA program office anytime. MBA program office is supporting the partners as well by organizing the events for partners. I expected that Tuck has supportive community but the supports from the community are more than I expected.
Another surprising thing was that we didn’t have much snow in the winter. Last winter, New England had the warmest winter in recent years and there was less snow than usual. Dean Danos visited Tokyo last winter and made a joke that Tokyo had more snow than Hanover. I don’t know what is going to happen this winter, but it is not bad to have a ‘real New England winter’ this winter, as long as it is one-time experience.

Adam: How would you describe the culture of the business school?

Tuck2013: In general, Tuck students are very team-oriented. They are basically attracted by the team-oriented culture in Tuck and thus they are very supportive and mature.  Tuck students are coming from all over the world and are very diverse but they certainly share the team-oriented mind. I also think MBA program office designs the program to preserve the team oriented culture. In almost every class, we are required the group assignment and in some classes we are evaluated by our peers.
I think that the classmates in Tuck are like family. I actually spent vast amount of time with my study-group mates in the first year and we could develop the very good tie. Even outside of study, Students living in the dorms spend literally 24/7 with classmates and students living off-campus also participate in the event on-campus very frequently. Due to the amount of time spent with classmates, we know our classmates very well and I believe that the relationship with classmates is deeper than other schools. I think this is a unique aspect of Tuck.

Adam: What are hot topics, activities, classes, etc. at your school right now?

Tuck2013: The hottest project in Tuck is probably $300 project. This project was initiated by Prof. Vijay Govindarajan. He is one of the best strategy professors in Tuck and was ranked No. 3 in Thinkers 50 in 2011. The concept of $300 house is to make the house affordable to people in the poor region. Now the project is making a pilot version of $300 houses and expected to be in full implementation in two or three years. Entire Dartmouth community is supporting this project. Now Tuck team is cooperating with engineer school team to build a pilot version. Former President of Dartmouth College, Jong Yong Kim strongly supported $300 house project and he was nominated to World Bank chief by President Obama. His nomination is another big topic for Tuck and Dartmouth community.

Adam: What are you doing this summer?

Tuck2013: I’m doing internship in a private equity fund in Boston. I’m engaged in due diligence of new investment opportunity and monitoring of the current portfolio. I’m also involved in the project to identify the next market segment we should focus on.
I found the job by the referral from Tuck alum. Tuck alum network is tight and really helpful for job searching. Also, Career Development Office (CDO) helped me a lot. Counselors in CDO have each specialized industry like banking and consulting and help us out with their personal network and experience. Due to these strong supports, Tuck has the successful record in recruiting.   

Adam:  What advice do you have for those considering application to your school?

Tuck2013: Tuck is kind of special environment. We call it as “Tuck bubble” which is like a two-year camp with classmates. Very few students are local in New Hampshire or Vermont. Most of students are coming from outside and Hanover is a nice town but it doesn’t have many amusement spots or fancy bars and restaurants. So the natural conclusion for the students is that they spend much time in Tuck and hang out with their classmates.  In “Tuck bubble”, we can’t avoid mingling with classmates. Not everybody can adapt to this environment. So I think that the fit to Tuck community is very important. If you like such an environment and want to enjoy two years with your classmates on the beautiful campus in Hanover, Tuck is a good school for you.
Also in terms of academics, Tuck may not be for everyone, because Tuck is a small school and the number of electives is limited, though I think the quality of faculty is really good. The focus of Tuck MBA program is general management and the program is not for specialists. Thus for the applicants who want to develop their expertise deeply, Tuck may not be a good fit.
I think Tuck has several unique characteristics. Showing the fit to these unique aspects is a convincing way to explain “Why Tuck”, which is the most important question both in essays and interview.   

Adam:  Are there any specific websites or blogs that you would recommend that applicants look at to learn more about your school?

Tuck2013: I think that the Admission Blog is a helpful resource for the applicants to get the insights from the admission staff and current students.
Also we are now preparing Tuck Connections which connects applicants with current Tuck students and alumni.
I’m planning to renew the Japanese Tuck Website this year to provide the updated information about Tuck. So if you are a Japanese applicant, please check out the Japanese Tuck Website as well.

Adam: Anything else you would like to tell us?

Tuck2013: Tuck campus is beautiful and Hanover is a small but nice town. It is really hard to describe how attractive they are. It is also difficult to explain the culture in Tuck only with this Q&A. I recommend visiting campus and feel the Tuck culture, if you are interested in Tuck. We will always welcome you!!
-----------------------------------


I want to thank Tuck2013 for taking the time to put together some really great insights into the Tuck experience.


-Adam Markus

I am a graduate admissions consultant who works with clients worldwide. If you would like to arrange an initial consultation, please complete my intake form. Please don't email me any essays, other admissions consultant's intake forms, your life story, or any long email asking for a written profile assessment. The only profiles I assess are those with people who I offer initial consultations to. Please note that initial consultations are not offered when I have reached full capacity or when I determine that I am not a good fit with an applicant.

July 03, 2012

My 2011-2012 Admissions Season in Retrospect

I wanted to provide a final take on the 2011-2012 admissions season for my clients.  Here are my select client results for 2009-2012:
MBA Comprehensive Service Client Select Results 2009-2012
School2012201120102009Total
Cambridge1 client applied and withdrew after admission to LBS2237
Columbia635216
Cornell Johnson02114
Chicago Booth544417
Duke2 2228
HBS41027
IESENo clients applied for 2012 2327
IMD 11215
INSEAD763216
Kellogg432413
LBS232310
Michigan (2Y, not GMBA) 24219
MIT626115
OxfordNo clients applied for 2012 32510
Stanford GSB23218
Tuck12216
UC Berkeley Haas 11114
UCLA 11158
Wharton712515
Clients in various years also admitted to Stanford Sloan, MIT Sloan Masters, NYU MBA, Yale MBA, and other top MBA programs. Results above are only for my comprehensive clients and do not include interview-only clients admitted to HBS, Stanford, MIT, Wharton, Columbia, and other top programs. You can find my full client results and testimonials here.

LL.M. Clients
-->
I work with a small number of LL.M. clients who are consistently admitted to top US Law Schools. For 2012 admission, I worked with 5 clients: One client was admitted to Yale, another was admitted to Harvard, and  one or more clients were admitted to Berkeley, Chicago, Columbia, Cornell, Georgetown, PENN, and UCLA. In 2011 and 2010, I worked with only 1 LL.M. client, in both years, my clients were accepted to Columbia. In 2009, 2 LL.M. clients were admitted to Harvard and another client was accepted at Columbia. 
Given that 2011-2012 was my tenth year as a graduate admissions consultant, I can honestly say it was the best ever. I have had the opportunity to work with an incredibly diverse range of remarkable people from Bangladesh, Czech Republic, Canada, France, Germany, Hong Kong, India, Italy, Japan, Singapore, South Korea, United States, Taiwan, and Turkey. "My results" are theirs, I merely helped. I thank them for choosing to take my advice and putting in the hard work necessary to get into the world's top MBA programs. 

I celebrated my tenth season by traveling with my wife from April to the middle of June to Singapore, Turkey, Germany, France, Spain, Portugal, The Netherlands, Luxembourg, Belgium, The Czech Republic, Israel, Austria, Bulgaria and Switzerland, but not necessarily in that order. It was a long and amazing trip. Along the way, I visited IESE in April and IMD in May. Since getting back to Tokyo I have been having initial consultations with potential clients and I am already starting to work with some clients on their first round applications. I am back writing the blog on a more or less constant basis and hope to have many posts up in July and August before I get real busy.


-Adam Markus

I am a graduate admissions consultant who works with clients worldwide. If you would like to arrange an initial consultation, please complete my intake form. Please don't email me any essays, other admissions consultant's intake forms, your life story, or any long email asking for a written profile assessment. The only profiles I assess are those with people who I offer initial consultations to. Please note that initial consultations are not offered when I have reached full capacity or when I determine that I am not a good fit with an applicant.

HBS MBA 2+2 Class of 2017 Application

This is the eighth in series of eight posts. My analysis of the HBS Application for the Class of 2015 (and 2+2 Class of 2017) consists of:
My comprehensive service clients have been admitted to the regular HBS MBA for the Classes of 2014, 2013, 2011, 2010, 2009, 2008, 2007, and 2005 and one 2+2 client admitted to the Class of 2014. My clients' results and testimonials can be found here. In addition to providing comprehensive application counseling on HBS, I regularly help additional candidates with HBS interview preparation. I have worked with a large number of applicants from Canada, Europe, India, Japan, other parts of Asia, and the United States on HBS application. I think that this range of experience has helped me understand the many possible ways of making an effective application to HBS. In the posts in this series, I provide insights based on that experience.

2+2 Program
This will be the shortest of my posts in this series because from an application viewpoint there are only two differences between applying for the MBA Class of 2015 and the applying to join the 2+2 Program for the Class of 2014:
As the second point is not actually something I need to discuss, we have only the issue of recommendations, which is certainly worth considering. After discussing recommendations, I will discuss three issues that I consider worth mentioning.

Two Recommendations
Before reading any further I suggest you first review my main post on HBS recommendations.  Many college students will find it useful to have an academic recommendation, but this is not strictly speaking necessary. If you think your recommenders from your work or extracurricular activities will be better, it is reasonable to use them.  Keep in mind that the person should be in real position of superiority and not your peer.  A supervisor from a meaningful part-time job or internship would certainly be appropriate. If you have served as a research assistant, grader, or teaching assistant to a professor, that can also work quite well. If you think that you don't have any useful non-academic references, just use the two professors who you think know you best and will be able to support your application the most effectively.

Who is the 2+2 Program for?
In other words, they are looking for academically accomplished college students who have clear leadership potential and demonstrated analytical skills. Based on my limited experience working with 2+2 applicants (1 admit in 2009, 1 ding after interview in 2011, and 1 ding without interview in 2010), this program is best for those who have a truly outstanding background. My one client who was dinged without interview was solid, but compared to both the admit and the client dinged after interview, not impressive. I would at this point only work with a client on 2+2 if they were truly outstanding. A combination of clear academic abilities, demonstrated leadership (this should be conceived in a very broad way and need not take the form of just running some sort of organization or activity), community engagement, and that highly subjective quality of just being someone who stands out from their peers, makes for the best candidate for this program. It is clearly for high achievers.

Interviewing for 2+2
Please read my main post on interviewing at HBS. Take this interview very seriously and be very prepared for it. From the reports I have read, HBS admissions officers don't really treat 2+2 applicants especially gently.  If you have limited experience interviewing, you really need to get practice and feedback from an admissions consultant, someone with significant experience as an interviewer, an interview coach, and/or HBS students and alumni.  Ideally, a combination of these would be best.  Don't just rely on your parents, siblings, and friends unless they fit into the categories I previously mentioned.

Alternatives to HBS 2+2? Stanford GSB! 
No other MBA program offers something like 2+2 in terms of being a program that is designed to support admits before they actually enter the MBA program.  That said, Stanford GSB does offer both direct and deferred enrollment to the MBA program to college seniors. Like HBS, they encourage promising college seniors to apply. They are looking for exactly the same sort of profile as HBS. The deferred enrollment option allows for college seniors to work for one to three years prior to entering Stanford. Details can found here.  I would encourage applicants to 2+2 to also consider application to Stanford.  While neither program is easy to get into, admission or rejection from one for strong candidates does not have any baring on how you will do at the other.  If you would be happy attending either of these schools, I do recommend making application to both of them.


-Adam Markus

I am a graduate admissions consultant who works with clients worldwide. If you would like to arrange an initial consultation, please complete my intake form. Please don't email me any essays, other admissions consultant's intake forms, your life story, or any long email asking for a written profile assessment. The only profiles I assess are those with people who I offer initial consultations to. Please note that initial consultations are not offered when I have reached full capacity or when I determine that I am not a good fit with an applicant.
Real Time Web Analytics